Natural gas suppliers face criticism over Texas electricity crisis
Texas, the fossil fuel hub of the United States, was abandoned by its natural gas delivery system last week energy crisis, according to the head of the country’s leading independent power producer.
Critical comments from Curt Morgan, chief executive of Vistra, one of the U.S. electric power industry’s largest consumers of natural gas and coal, were addressed to a panel investigating the emergency on Thursday.
Generators powered by gas, wind, coal and nuclear power all faltered during the record-breaking freeze that left more than 30 dead. The generational collapse has led some politicians to blame renewable energy sources to the exclusion of others.
But Morgan said the bigger problem was with gas supply to the gas-powered generators, given their dominant share in supplying the Texas grid.
“The big story here,” Morgan said at a Texas House of Representatives committee hearing, “was the failure of the gas system to work.”
Irving-based Vistra has 19 generators in Texas with a capacity of over 18 gigawatts, most of which burn fossil fuels.
Comments from its CEO deflected concerns that Texas power producers had not adequately armed their own equipment against the elements. Vistra was prepared for winter and spent an additional $ 10 million to prepare her factories for the approaching storm, Morgan said.
Gas-fired power plants represent more than half of generation capacity in the state’s largely siled electricity market. Morgan said gas delivery problems ranged from frozen wellheads to processing plants losing power to pipelines unable to supply enough fuel.
About 90% of Vistra’s gas fleet in Texas was available, but it was only operating at 75% of capacity. “We just couldn’t get the gas at the pressures we needed,” Morgan said.
Mauricio Gutierrez, managing director of NRG Energy – another prominent generator operating in Texas – said gas pressure “problems” had twice triggered its 330-megawatt Greens Bayou power plant.
“If the natural gas system is compromised, the electrical system will be compromised,” he said.
Thad Hill, chief executive of Houston-based Calpine, said two of the company’s dozen gas-fired power plants in Texas had shut down due to freezing conditions. Another set of factories were shut down during the grid frequency cascading drop in early February 15. However, stopping the gas flow accounted for the largest share of the failures.
On February 16, “40 percent of our deliveries were cut by suppliers,” Hill said. “There were times during this event where 60% or more of our offline total was related to gas supply.”
More than 52 gigawatts of the state’s 108 GW of installed capacity were offline at the worst time last week, Bill Magness, chief executive of the Texas Electrical Reliability Council (Ercot) said Wednesday in a presentation. A rapid drop in power supplies led to the dangerous drop in frequency that threatened to permanently damage the grid, he said.
He said his nonprofit carried out spot checks of climate aging practices at about 80 power plants a year out of the 680 total spread across Texas.
Gutierrez said all plants at NRG are prepared for winter each September. But he said climate change should prompt power companies to modify their models for extreme weather conditions.
“We’re going to be looking at our wintering programs with a new baseline, with a new baseline that has been set by this unprecedented winter storm,” he said.
Wholesale electricity prices in the Ercot market hit their allowable maximum of $ 9,000 per megawatt hour last week, compared to an average of around $ 25. The high price is intended to encourage consumers to ration and to encourage investment in sufficient production capacity.
Texas market is unique to the United States in that generators make money on the energy they sell, but not to keep their capacity in reserve.
“I was a big supporter of this deal, and my faith was shaken,” Morgan said.
Energy is the world’s essential business and Energy Source is its newsletter. Every Tuesday and Thursday, straight to your inbox, Energy Source brings you essential news, cutting-edge analysis and insider information. register here.